Career Management

November 11, 2026

How to Communicate Better With Your Manager When Things Aren't Working

Communication problems with your manager can affect your workload, performance, and career development. Learn how to identify what's creating friction, discuss expectations and priorities, request useful feedback, and recognize when communication alone may not resolve the problem.

How to Communicate Better With Your Manager When Things Aren't Working

You've explained what you need from your manager, but the conversation doesn't seem to change anything. Or perhaps you've avoided bringing up a problem because you're uncertain how your manager will respond, and you're hoping the situation will improve on its own.

Before deciding you need to communicate more often or be more direct, consider what's contributing to the problem. Unclear expectations, different working styles, competing priorities, and organizational limitations can create similar frustrations, but they don't necessarily call for the same solution.

Identify What's Creating the Communication Problem

When communication with your manager becomes frustrating, identifying the specific behaviors or situations contributing to the problem can help you determine what needs to change.

You might describe your manager as a micromanager because they're requesting frequent updates, questioning your decisions, or becoming involved in work you've previously handled independently. Although these behaviors can create similar frustrations, each may require a different conversation. Feeling unsupported can be equally difficult to address when you haven't determined whether you need clearer direction, more useful feedback, additional resources, or help prioritizing responsibilities.

Before approaching your manager, consider:

  • What's working well in our communication?
  • Which situations or behaviors are creating problems?
  • How are those problems affecting my work or professional development?

As you evaluate the relationship, distinguish what you've observed from what you're assuming about your manager's intentions. Frequent requests for updates could reflect concerns about a deadline, pressure from senior leadership, or difficulty delegating, and you may not know which explanation applies until you have a conversation.

Clarify Expectations and Competing Priorities

Employees and managers don't always have the same understanding of what needs to happen, when it needs to happen, or what successful work looks like. These differences become particularly challenging when responsibilities change without a corresponding discussion about priorities.

Following layoffs, an employee who inherits additional responsibilities may struggle to meet existing deadlines while their manager underestimates how much time the additional work requires. Rather than waiting until commitments become unrealistic, explaining the workload and recommending how responsibilities should be prioritized gives the manager an opportunity to clarify expectations.

Example: Discussing competing priorities

"I've taken on these additional responsibilities, and I want to make sure I'm prioritizing the right work. Here's the order I'm planning to tackle everything. Does that align with what you need, or would you change anything?"

A brief written follow-up can provide a reference for agreed-upon priorities if circumstances change. However, when a manager continues assigning more work than an employee can reasonably complete, clarifying expectations may need to be followed by conversations about deadlines, available resources, or whether the workload is sustainable.

Understand Your Manager's Communication Preferences

Some managers want frequent progress updates, while others prefer employees to work independently and raise concerns when something requires their attention. Differences in these preferences can become particularly frustrating for experienced professionals who've developed their own approaches to managing responsibilities.

If you've spent years working independently, reporting to someone who wants to review decisions before they're made may feel restrictive, especially when you've consistently demonstrated sound judgment. Before assuming the additional oversight reflects a lack of trust, consider what information your manager needs and whether there's a less disruptive way to provide it.

For example, if your manager regularly requests project updates throughout the week, you could suggest a recurring summary covering progress, upcoming decisions, and potential problems. They may welcome the arrangement, prefer something different, or have reporting requirements that limit their flexibility.

As a manager, I sometimes had to navigate organizational circumstances that affected my team but weren't entirely within my control, and I've also worked under managers who were responsible for implementing decisions they didn't necessarily make or support. Those experiences have influenced how I evaluate manager relationships because organizational pressures can explain certain decisions, although they don't excuse a manager who consistently refuses to clarify expectations or address reasonable concerns.

Understanding whether your manager is responding to leadership requests, resource limitations, or organizational policies can help you determine which concerns they have the authority to address and which may require a broader organizational solution.

Address Concerns Before Frustration Builds

When your manager repeatedly changes priorities after work has already started, accommodating those changes can become increasingly frustrating if you don't understand how they affect your other commitments. You may begin questioning whether your manager respects your time or recognizes your workload, particularly when the changes happen without any discussion of what should be deprioritized.

Professionals sometimes avoid these conversations because they don't want to appear difficult or aren't confident their manager will respond constructively. While occasional changes may not warrant a discussion, recurring disruptions deserve attention when they're affecting your ability to work effectively.

For example:

"When priorities change after we've started a project, I'm finding it difficult to manage the deadlines for my other commitments. Could we discuss how you'd like me to handle those situations and which responsibilities should take precedence?"

Your manager may have information you weren't aware of when making your original plans, and certain changes may be unavoidable. Discussing how competing priorities should be managed can still help you make decisions without repeatedly guessing which responsibilities matter most.

Ask for Feedback That Supports Your Development

Experienced professionals can encounter communication challenges when their managers provide limited feedback or lack the expertise to evaluate certain aspects of their work. You may consistently meet expectations and receive positive performance reviews without learning much about how to continue developing, particularly if your manager doesn't have a background in your functional area.

Rather than relying on general questions such as "How am I doing?", ask about specific projects, responsibilities, or opportunities you're interested in pursuing.

  • What worked well in how I handled that project?
  • What would you have preferred I approach differently?
  • Which responsibilities could help me prepare for future opportunities?
  • Are there skills or experiences that would make me more effective in my current role?

Communicating your professional interests is also important because consistent performance doesn't necessarily tell your manager what you want from your career. Someone who performs well in their current position may be viewed as satisfied with their responsibilities, even when they're interested in developing different skills or exploring another area of the organization.

If your manager can't provide the feedback or development support you need, colleagues, mentors, or other professional relationships may offer perspectives that complement what you receive from your manager.

Recognize When Communication Has Limits

Although you can clarify expectations, adjust how you share information, and initiate difficult conversations, improving the relationship also depends on how your manager responds. After making reasonable efforts to address a recurring problem, consider whether expectations are becoming clearer, agreements are being honored, and conversations are producing meaningful changes.

If the same problems continue, you may need additional support or a broader evaluation of how the relationship is affecting your work and career. Harassment, discrimination, retaliation, and other serious concerns require particular consideration because they may call for documentation, appropriate reporting, or qualified external guidance rather than continued attempts to improve communication.

Sometimes a conversation that doesn't produce the outcome you hoped for can still provide useful information about what your manager is willing or able to address, even if it leaves you with another decision to make.

In my Control Your Career podcast episode, How to Improve Your Relationship With Your Manager, I explore four strategies for strengthening the relationship and three possible outcomes to consider when deciding what makes sense for your career.

Watch or listen to How to Improve Your Relationship With Your Manager.

----------------

Julia Toothacre, MS, is a career coach, strategist, and founder of Ride The Tide Collective. Through her Control Your Career methodology, she helps experienced professionals navigate career challenges, evaluate their options, and make informed decisions grounded in their individual circumstances, priorities, and goals.

‍

Related Posts

Branded graphic displaying the title What to Do When You Have a Difficult Relationship With Your Manager
Career Management

What to Do When You Have a Difficult Relationship With Your Manager

A difficult relationship with your manager can affect your performance, professional development, and job satisfaction. Explore how to identify what's causing problems, understand your manager's limitations, and evaluate whether the relationship can improve or whether it's time to consider other options.

Experienced professional working with colleagues in a workplace setting
Career Management
Career Advancement

How to Build a Strong Reputation at Work

Your workplace reputation develops through the patterns people experience when they work with you. Learn how to understand what you're currently known for, decide what you want to be known for, and recognize where workplace culture and perception may be influencing your reputation.

Career Management
Workplace & Labor Market

Your Company Is Introducing AI. What Should Employees Do?

Is your employer introducing AI? Learn what to ask your manager, how to evaluate workplace changes, and what AI adoption could mean for your career.

Two people working on laptops at a desk with bright sunlight streaming through windows behind them.

Take Back Control of Your Career

One honest conversation is the fastest way to find out if this is the plan you've been looking for.