When Success No Longer Feels Like Success with Melissa O’Hara
What happens when you've built a successful career but no longer feel fulfilled by your work? Melissa O'Hara joins Julia Toothacre to discuss changing priorities, recognizing your strengths, and exploring new career opportunities through small experiments.
Resources Mentioned
Melissa's E-Book: Stop Fixing Yourself: How to Elevate What's Wrong to Achieve More in Work and Life
Melissa's Paperback Book: Stop Fixing Yourself: How to Elevate What's Wrong to Achieve More in Work and Life
Guests

Melissa O'Hara
Share
Watch
Listen
Overview
Melissa O’Hara joins Julia Toothacre to discuss how to find career clarity when you are already successful but no longer feel fully satisfied with the path you have built. Drawing from Melissa’s own transitions from finance to HR and then into entrepreneurship, they explore changing priorities, energy, outside expectations, small career experiments, and how experienced professionals can figure out what comes next without forcing an immediate answer.
Show Notes
A successful career can be difficult to question precisely because so much has gone right. You may have built expertise, earned a strong reputation, increased your income, and reached goals that once mattered deeply to you. Then something shifts. You are still capable of doing the work, but you are less energized by it, your priorities have changed, or the version of success you once wanted no longer feels satisfying.
In this episode, Julia Toothacre speaks with Melissa O’Hara, founder of O’Hara Solutions Group, executive coach, leadership consultant, and creator of Horizon Life Design®. Melissa’s own career includes several significant pivots, including moving from finance into HR inside a financial services company and later leaving corporate leadership to start her own business. Her experience provides a practical example of changing direction without treating the earlier part of a career as wasted time.
Melissa explains that one of her earliest clues came from paying attention to energy. She was highly capable in finance and responsible for significant work, but many of the activities central to the role consistently exhausted her. Training, presenting, and coaching people had the opposite effect. Rather than immediately leaving the company, she asked her manager for more opportunities to do that kind of work, which eventually allowed her to test a different function and build advocates before making a full transition.
That story leads into a broader discussion about conventional success and the pressure high achievers can feel to keep pursuing the next title, salary increase, or respected role. Melissa encourages professionals to notice the career “shoulds” they have absorbed from family, colleagues, culture, or earlier versions of themselves and to ask whether those expectations still belong in the decision they are making now.
Julia and Melissa also discuss Melissa’s energy grid, a simple practice of tracking what gives and drains energy across both work and life. The exercise is useful because assumptions are often inaccurate. Someone who identifies as introverted, for example, may assume that people-oriented work is draining, only to discover that certain conversations are energizing while solitary tasks are the real problem. The goal is to collect evidence rather than rely on a broad label.
The conversation then turns to clarity through action. Melissa recommends turning career question marks into exclamation points by taking the smallest possible action that produces useful information. That might mean talking with someone in the field, watching how a company operates, testing a responsibility through a project, or trying a small version of the work before committing to a larger transition. The goal is to learn, not to prove that every idea was the right one.
They also address the pressure high achievers feel to make the right decision on the first try. Melissa argues that this pressure can make people less flexible and less willing to experiment. Instead, she encourages professionals to pay attention to what matters in their current season, compare their actions with the priorities they say they value, and choose collaborators who can support the stage of exploration they are actually in.
For someone who knows something needs to change but does not yet know what comes next, Melissa recommends starting with strengths and energy. Identify what you are good at, notice which of those capabilities give you energy, and ask trusted people what they see you doing exceptionally well. Those patterns can provide a stronger starting point than choosing a job title first and trying to force yourself into it.
What Julia and Melissa Discuss
• Why accomplished professionals can begin questioning a career they worked hard to build
• What Melissa learned from moving from finance into HR and later leaving corporate leadership
• How asking for specific opportunities can create internal career options
• Why a lateral or lower-level move can be the right strategic choice in a particular season
• How to separate your own career priorities from the “shoulds” you have absorbed from other people
• How to use an energy grid to identify patterns in what gives and drains your energy
• Why writing down career observations creates better evidence than relying on memory
• How clarity through action turns uncertainty into useful information
• Why a “heck no” can be just as valuable as a “heck yes” when testing a career possibility
• How high achievers can use strengths, priorities, and trusted collaborators to explore what comes next
About Melissa O’Hara
Melissa O’Hara is the founder of O’Hara Solutions Group, executive coach, leadership consultant, and creator of Horizon Life Design®, a framework that helps high-achieving professionals create careers and lives they are excited to live. Her own career includes multiple transitions, from finance into human resources and organizational effectiveness, followed by a deliberate move out of corporate leadership to build her own company.
Through coaching, speaking, and leadership development, Melissa helps professionals gain clarity, make confident decisions, and align their work with the priorities and strengths that matter in their current season. She is also the author of the upcoming book The Five-Percent Factor, which focuses on achieving more by elevating what is already strong rather than concentrating disproportionate attention on what needs to be fixed.



